What can one new customer cost you?
Take a typical sale and subtract the direct cost of doing the work. In this example, a $1,200 job uses $700 in labor and materials, leaving $500. The owner chooses to keep $350 per job for overhead and profit. That leaves up to $150 to get one new customer. Use recent invoices for the service you want to promote. An emergency repair and a full replacement may need different limits.
How do you turn that amount into a lead target?
Multiply your allowable cost per customer by the share of qualified inquiries that book. Suppose 3 of the last 12 qualified inquiries for that $1,200 service became jobs. The booking rate is 25%, so the business can spend up to $150 × 0.25, or $37.50 per qualified inquiry. If the next group books at only one in eight, the target falls to $18.75. Keep leads with decisions still pending in a separate group.
Which costs belong in an agency comparison?
Put the same expenses on both sides of the comparison. If a campaign costs $450 in ads and $150 in management and brings 12 qualified inquiries, the ad-only cost is $37.50 each. The full cost is $50 each. At the booking rate in this example, the three new customers cost $200 each to acquire, above the owner’s $150 limit. Ask each agency to itemize platform spend, management, creative work and tracking.
How large a test can your team handle?
Work back from open capacity. At a 25% booking rate, filling four openings would take about 16 qualified inquiries. At the $37.50 target, that allows $600 in total acquisition costs for the test. Pick a review date that gives those inquiries time to book. Bring the actual spend, the job outcomes and the unanswered calls to that review before increasing the budget.